James Marsters Teases Spike Return in Buffy: New Sunnydale

James Marsters has confirmed that there is active interest in his return to the Sunnydale universe for the upcoming Hulu continuation series, Buffy: New Sunnydale.

The actor, who famously portrayed the beloved British vampire Spike, shared his thoughts on a potential reprisal during a recent podcast appearance, offering fans a glimpse into what the future might hold for the iconic character.

Speaking on Charisma Carpenter's The Bitch is Back podcast, Marsters disclosed that he had recently rewatched the classic Buffy the Vampire Slayer series. The purpose of this revisit was to attempt to 'get back' into the headspace of playing Spike, a character he has been associated with for decades.

However, he cautioned that any on-screen return would likely not be imminent. When asked directly about his involvement, Marsters was careful with his wording, stating:

I am not, I have no idea... let's see, what can I say... There is interest in having me back.

This statement marks the first time a classic Buffy era actor has indicated potential involvement in the new series, following Sarah Michelle Gellar's previous comments about wanting to include other legacy characters.

Marsters provided a logical timeline for when fans might expect to see Spike, should his return be finalized. He suggested that the production team should focus on establishing the new world and its characters before introducing returning favorites.

'If I was producing the reboot, I wouldn't call me yet,' he explained. 'I would have to do the origin story of the new slayer, I would have to introduce all of her friends, I would have to set up the new world, and I would have to get them into at least one new adventure together before I dropped in any other characters.'

Based on this narrative structure, Marsters anticipates a later arrival:

• Earliest appearance: End of season one
• Possible timeline: Into season two
• Current expectation: Surprised if called now
• Final sentiment: Would be surprised if not called eventually

The Hulu continuation series is currently still finalizing plans for its first season. The project, which is being worked on by Sarah Michelle Gellar, shot its pilot episode last summer but has not yet announced a release date or resumed production.

Gellar has previously emphasized the importance of getting the series right, noting that she understands the audience's desire for content but is unwilling to rush the process. She stated that work continues behind the scenes to ensure the show meets the high standards set for it.

The series aims to introduce a new Slayer and her friends, with Gellar herself expected to have a relatively minor role in the pilot before transitioning to a recurring character. This approach allows the narrative to focus on the next generation while leaving room for legacy characters to appear organically.

The character of Spike originated as a villain in the second season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, initially intended for only a brief appearance. His immense popularity led to him becoming a series regular and a core part of the show, eventually transferring to the spin-off Angel when the original series concluded.

Spike's relationship with Buffy remains one of the most debated storylines in the series' history. His fate in Angel was left on a cliffhanger due to the show's cancellation, leaving fans curious about where the past 20 years have taken the character.

If Spike does return to Buffy: New Sunnydale, it would provide a significant bridge between the classic series and the new continuation, offering long-time fans a familiar anchor in the updated universe.

The confirmation of interest in James Marsters' return represents a promising development for fans of the original Buffy universe. While the timeline remains uncertain, the logical narrative approach suggested by Marsters indicates a thoughtful integration of legacy characters.

As Buffy: New Sunnydale continues to develop its first season, the potential return of Spike adds another layer of anticipation to the project. The series is positioned to honor the original while carving out its own identity, with Marsters' return serving as a potential bridge between eras.

For now, fans await further news on production schedules and release dates, with the understanding that quality takes precedence over speed in bringing this beloved universe back to screens.